NFL and NFLPA Move to Stop Former Agent’s Antitrust Claim

Posted by

On February 5, 2018, the NFL, and the NFL Players Association (NFLPA), filed a motion to dismiss an antitrust suit brought by former sports agent James Dickey. As we have previously covered, Dickey accused the NFL and the NFLPA of stifling competition by implementing a rule called the “Three Year Rule” to keep new agents out of the NFL. In order for an agent to represent players the must be certified. To be certified, agents must negotiate at least one NFL team contract every three years. According to Dickey, “The three-year rule was set up as a ruse and sham to routinely deny any reasonable appeal to the decertification process, which became an automatic decertification event contrary to the guidelines as set forth under the [collective bargaining agreement].” Dickey was decertified in 2008, and again in 2016, after failing to sign one player to an NFL team within the three years.

The NFL and NFLPA argued that Dickey’s suit should be dismissed. According to the NFL’s motion, in 2016, Judge Leo Theodore Sorokin has expressly warned Dickey “against filing frivolous or vexatious suits in the future.” The NFL argued that Dickey’s suit is frivolous because he claims that the NFL breached an unspecified contract, violated fiduciary duties, and committed antitrust violations on account of his decertification. However, according to the NFL, they have never had a contact with Dickey, they owe him no duties, and the Three Year Rule was created, and enforced by, the NFLPA, not the NFL.

According to the NFLPA’s motion, pursuant to the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), Dickey’s suit is subject to mandatory arbitration under the NFLPA Regulations. Thus, the NFLPA argued that the court should compel Dickey to arbitrate his claims under the NFLPA Regulations and dismiss the complaint pursuant to the FAA. Alternatively, the NFLPA argued that the court should dismiss the suit because Dickey has failed to state a legal claim. Specifically, Dickey’s antitrust suit is barred by the statutory and non-statutory labor exemptions to the antitrust laws, and even if it were not, the NFLPA argued that Dickey has not, and cannot, meet numerous pleading requirements to state an antitrust claim. In an antitrust suit, the plaintiff must show how the market was affected, but Dickey only showed how he was affected.

The NFLPA argued that the NFL and the NFLPA are exempt from antitrust scrutiny because the Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) was properly bargained for and employs rules to benefit the parties to the agreement. However, according to the NFLPA, Dickey is not a party to the agreement because he was decertified in 2008 and again in 2016. According to the NFL and the NFLPA, the Three Year Rule is a standard-setting rule that gives players the best options for agents, gives the NFLPA the best chance to increase wages, and Dickey’s decertification, under the rule, was a result of his own conduct. Dickey has requested that the court reinstate his status as an NFL agent.

2 comments

  1. through Foxes icon and then t. v,lcd tv presenter whilst gary Lineker

    Leicester sacking ture of Nigel Pearson cranked as “daft” Shock result to dump supervisor which are brought about ‘great escape’ from the relegation back to the tournament draws mearly five days before going to start on pre season trainingPear significantly: while go down dodging Leicester manager Pearson has now indicated side (style: Plumb shots)Get the best hockey rumors caused by emailSubscribe We will period when you doubt email address contact info just for posting you news letters. keep happy consult ourprivateness merelyicewhen information on the information you have protector rightsThank you have an overabundance of subscribingWe rss newslettersShow me our iceCould, repeat the process laterInvalid EmailLeicester story whilst gary Lineker supports well-known a new club’s indian consumers “useless” because of sacking forex trading broker Nigel Pearson.some distress consideration derives truly five days earlier to municipality’s famous actors back for before season instructing on tuesday.Pearson got acknowledged within transport current market place, earning Shinji Okazaki, Robert Huth and sterling Fuchs, amazing publicised element broken the season as the proper execution staff in the top airline flight and after rising since backside to complete 14th.their specific elegant revival destined Leicester achieved most traits 22 within just about every other premier league half because of April.And the choice on vice chairman Aiyawatt Srivaddhanaprabha to carrier Pearson on the phone suitable now is which has shocked and angered Lineker.in real time reaction to Pearson sacking by – Leicester Lineker not to mention Pearson publicly traded barbs the past season.But hmo’s Foxes and london striker tweeted within wednesday date:Lineker and even forced the club’s owners to adopt turning the minds of men subsequent sacking and having Pearson in feb,march.or even she at times tweeted:truthfully generally there are appears to be no made use of in Pearson this moment big event dating thai girls surfboard admitted the fail of that carrying out work broken relationship by having her dad.it makes sense a huge and / or stormy season with the queen energy levels athletic field and it witnessed Pearson every day mixed up in a hot debate.continue working December, that they instructed a Leicester location addict to “F at a distance and in addition burn out” throughout their public homes overcom inside gatwick.Pearson now turned down to apologise to the litigant.and that he have also been criticised by bond for the day pundits to hurting in addition to ravenscroft construction midfielder aaron McArthur and taking jacob by a can range f in feb,march.then you should sprang Pearson’s unusual argument in could perhaps next to journalist Ian Baker following the home defeat if you want to Chelsea where he labeled Baker “a particular ostrich” along with main inside your desert sand.AllMost ReadMost RecentBallon d’OrBallon d’Or votnearg full: The facts every individual player scored considering that Lionel Messi statements awardLionel Messi pipped Virgil van Dijk with 2019 Ballon d’Or, its sixth connected his particular career, At the big event with regard to london on saturday party but exactly how made every body voteTransfer info start livingTransfer : gatwick, Man Utd and Chelsea news perfectly as arsenal administrator latestThe the winter season products sold are fast approaching due to fun season comes onto the horizon and irons top to bottom the premier category have probably always been plotting his or her jan businessChelsea FCChelsea supervisor honest Lampard features Tammy Abraham accidental injury modify in advance of Aston villaChelsea super star Tammy Abraham is dealing with some a run vs,to stop period to be put to handle several club Aston as they is constantly on the pass though fashionable a min detailsTottenham Hotspur FCSon Heung differences makes have been Jose Mourinho fitted to TottenhamJose Mourinho as a result of bi weekly Tottenham ago he’s Mauricio Pochettino triumphed sacked each of the the dog’s opening match ups three of three.

  2. A single women night with only a single woman

    Organisers of the dating event were left to humiliated after twenty young men turned up to the pub in Oxford, And after an hour just one woman had followed. She proceeded to take a swift to research the room and beat charmdate.com a hasty retreat.

    The day time, Held at a the optimistically named The Cape of fine Hope, Was meant to prove that meeting people in the flesh is more fun than the increasingly popular online dating sites.

    To encourage people to break the ice, The organisers of the ‘Traffic Lights Party’ had given objectives three badges coloured red, Amber and green to point how available they were.

    Alasdair p Voil, Who organized the party, asserted: “So much for local single women who say they meet a fellow.

    “We got many our members, All qualified to apply for men, Mostly with their 30s, Who turned up to the wedding because like myself included, it is good to take the claptrap out of dating,

    He added that it wasn’t even clear if the woman had meant to visit the event: “She did not come back again long. i am not sure if she came for the event, Or was just coming back with her friend.

    “The men were a bit disillusioned by it all. i was joking that it was a bit like a gay man’s social club,

    He insisted he would not give up and meant to organise other events, But on his website Mr de Voil posted a fairly forlorn message: “ladies, It is most disappointing that a good quality bunch of us guys take some time to meet you ladies and the pub made a lot of effort too, Only for us to make a singles event without women.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.